Gavin Lane, Editor
Weapon degradation was a beautiful way to encourage experimentation in BOTW’s Hylian sandbox. I appreciated what it contributed to your journey through the game, and weapons were plentiful and varied enough to be worth trying just to see what they did, from elemental blade down to wooden spoon. Not once did I walk into a situation with nothing to hand; for me, the balance the devs struck there was masterful.
My sole irritation with the mechanic is based around the Master Sword, specifically the Level 60 maxed-out version I got once I passed all the DLC trials. I understand why, from a design perspective, it was given its own brand of durability earlier in the game and needed to be periodically ‘charged’. But once I had proven myself, beaten the trials, and gave Calamity Ganon a sound thrashing, it took the edge off my victory to find that the Blade of Evil’s Bane still ran out of juice.
So, it would be just dandy if the gnarly Master Sword we’ve glimpsed in TOTK – once sufficiently rejuvenated and tempered and whatnot – retained its masterfulness permanently at the very, very end of the game. Otherwise, summer degradation.
Kate Gray, Staff Writer
I honestly wasn’t bothered about weapon durability during my playthrough, but then a while after the game came out, it became this meme where everyone was bothered about it. But that hasn’t really changed my opinion! I think weapon durability can create these very organic moments where your sword explodes at the worst time during a boss battle, and I think those are worth something.
However… I still think it can be improved, because I’m pretty sure swords don’t actually explode, so I wouldn’t mind the durability system being switched to more of a Monster Hunter deal, where you have to keep your weapons sharp, and finding a sword is a rarer occurrence rather than swords existing in every nook and cranny of the world.
Alana Hagues, Staff Writer
To start off with, I wasn’t happy with the weapon durability in Breath of the Wild. I’m so used to going up to all enemies and attacking them in basically everything and I thought I could do the same here, willy-nilly. In the early hours of BOTW, I ran out of weapons a lot. I was often scrambling for resources, fighting my way through Hyrule using the Sheikah Slate, and throwing rocks or twigs at Moblins. Was I always effective? No. But was it fun? Yes.
I think that’s when I realized the beauty of BOTW’s weapon system. Everything in BOTW is basically an item. Something to be used, a resource to survive. Weapons were no exceptions. it didn’t matter if my ax snapped in two or if my sword shattered in my hand — something would be waiting for me nearby. And I’d need to learn how to do with it.
For Tears of the Kingdom, I’m almost 100% this mechanic will come back, but it’ll have some adjustments. Considering everything and their mother needs a crafting mechanic, I can totally see crafting being added to TOTK to my chagrin, but if Pokémon can do it, then Zelda can probably do it better. Make new weapons or fix up old ones? Sounds okay, right…?
Jim Norman, Staff Writer
I kind of loved weapon degradation in Breath of the Wild. What started as a frustrating journey with a pocket full o’ sticks soon became a tactical twist on the series format and something that I had a great time organizing. Finding a new weapon gave me huge amounts of joy and while there was much heartbreak involved when it broke before I had the chance to say goodbye, it made the adventure feel all the more fulfilling.
Of course, there is a certain amount of tweaking that I would like to see in Tears of the Kingdom. Making it so that weapons last that little bit longer would obviously be a bonus, but wouldn’t it also be nice to see us getting the ability to add some (limited) durability boosts onto some of our favorite weapons? This is a tricky one and would definitely need using in moderation — good job I’m not a game developer, hey — but it might make the sense of customization feel that little bit more personal.
It would also stop idiots like me from taking on the final phase of Ganon with nothing but a branch, but that’s a different matter, I suppose.
Ollie Reynolds, Staff Writer
Weapon durability never really bothered me. Honestly, reaching the max number of weapons in my inventory and having to sacrifice one to make room for a Savage Lynel Sword was a lot more irritating (though thankfully this eased as I found more and more Korok Seeds).
Like anything else though, it’s a mechanic that needs a bit of massaging, though what Nintendo does with this is beyond my comprehension right now. I did ponder the idea of having a one-time use item in the game that would grant one weapon unlimited durability, but that is rife with potential problems. Why would you even bother to use anything else if you have a weapon that deals decent damage and doesn’t break, for example?
I think the best thing Nintendo could do with this is to simply adjust the time it takes until a weapon completely breaks; maybe give us a bit more time with each weapon, or allow us to easily repair them. I don’t want Tears of the Kingdom to introduce crafting mechanics or something equally daft, but there’s definitely something to be explored here.
What do you want to see happen to TOTK’s weapons? Maybe they could take a tip out of Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity’s book and expand on the upgrade possibilities for individual weapons? Would you welcome more crafting-style mechanics? Fill out the following polls and then let us know in the comments.